2455 Shelby Street Indianapolis, IN 46203

Share
Presented By
Mike Thomas Associates
9601 Coldwater Road
Fort Wayne, IN 46825
(260) 489-2000
Email
Agent to Contact

By clicking "Send Message", you agree to be contacted by Sarah Hubley about your request. Please see our Privacy Policy.

Traditional • 125Y Old

$450,000

2455 Shelby Street

0.12 Acres
Property Description

Discover the inviting multi-family residence, a ready-to-move-in property awaiting its next chapter. The main level features 3 bedrooms and 1 bathroom. Two of the bedrooms, the bathroom, the living/dining area, and the kitchen are all located on the main floor, while the third bedroom is situated in a loft area upstairs that is spacious enough to include a seating area with built-in wooden shelves. Original trim, doors, and doorknobs add to the house's character. This section of the property has primarily been owner-occupied but could be rented for $1,400-$1,600 as a long-term rental and potentially for much more as a mid-term or short-term rental. The large basement houses the laundry area and is plumbed for an additional bathroom. It also contains a substantial furnace capable of heating the entire structure. However, separate mini-split systems provide heat and air conditioning for the upstairs apartments. Units 2 and 3 have their own exterior entrances and separate locked access on the second floor. Unit 2 is a studio apartment with an eat-in kitchen, while Unit 3 features a living area, bedroom and a kitchen. Both units have been rented out as mid-term rentals to traveling medical personnel for $1,100 and $1,200 per month, respectively. Furnishings are negotiable. There is also a huge attic space with a separate entrance that could be converted into a fourth apartment or used as a living/office space. The property includes a porch and a patio and the lot spans 5,009 square feet, providing ample space for various activities. Numerous upgrades make this property truly move-in ready and cash-flowing. This charming residence, located in the beautiful Garfield Park neighborhood, presents a unique opportunity to embrace comfortable living. You can either live in one area while renting out the other spaces on platforms platforms like Airbnb (short-term rental) or Furnished Finder (mid-term rental), or choose to rent out the entire property.

Directions

GPS Friendly

Map to 2455 Shelby Street, Indianapolis, IN 46203

Property
MLS # 22074045
Date Listed 2025-11-19
Status Active
Property Type Multi-Family/Apartments
Property SubType Triplex
New Construction No
Style Traditional
Type Triplex
Basement Interior Entry
Year Taxes Payable 2024
Year Built 1900
Days on Market 17
Additional
Design Traditional
Cooling Ductless
Heating Forced Air, Natural Gas
External Features
Construction Triplex
Lot Size 5,009 sq ft
Acreage 0.12 Acres
Fence None
Location
Area Marion
County Marion
Subdivision Spann & Halloway Shelby
Township Center
City Indianapolis
State IN
Zip 46203
Schools
School District Indianapolis Public Schools
Financial
Assoc. Dues $0.00

MLS# 22074045
Listing Provided Courtesy of Gloria Gear
Keller Williams Indy Metro S
gloria@gearregroup.com

Listing updated November 23, 2025 at 5:29 pm
Last checked 7 minutes ago

IDX information provided by the MIBOR REALTOR® Association. IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Data is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by the MLS.

Learn More About 2455 Shelby Street

Presented By
Mike Thomas Associates
9601 Coldwater Road
Fort Wayne, IN 46825
(260) 489-2000
Email
Agent to Contact

By clicking "Send Message", you agree to be contacted by Sarah Hubley about your request. Please see our Privacy Policy.